Site Review Scores

Wednesday, April 24, 2024

Welcome Home Voltron

Fleet Update 

Elektra - She is doing just fine.  20,000 miles since I got her 3 years ago.  My daily driver and errand runner.  She did complain a little during the coldest of days with a whine from her reduction gearbox.  I will get that fluid changed at her upcoming yearly maintenance interval.

Voltron - New addition to the fleet.  A 2023 Hyundai Ioniq 6, and this is the trip report for bringing him home.

Decision Making

After 3 years with Elektra, I knew I wanted to expand my fleet of electric vehicles. Based on the 3 years of ownership, the one thing I wanted in my next car was faster charging.  To that end, I thought I was going to go with a Genesis GV60, and that is what I had been looking for over the last 6 months.  But, when it came down to it, I realized, I still need and want a sedan and not a SUV.  After following deals on several GV60s, when I changed my mind to go to an Ioniq 6, an excellent deal immediately popped up in my first search. Once again I found the car in Illinois, just like Elektra, but this time instead of in the Chicago area, Voltron was for sale in the far west of Illinois, almost Iowa.  I called the next day and in a matter of hours had the deal agreed and started to make plans to travel to pick up the car.


Getting to the Dealership

Up very early I had booked an Uber to take me to the airport. I watched in the app as the driver stopped for gas before picking me up. Other than dropping me off at the wrong door, the ride was uneventful. I few from Detroit to Chicago to the Quad Cities.  Flying with United, which I don’t use and connecting through O’Hare; which surprisingly I have never flown through before.  From O’Hare, I flew to Moline, IL and the Quad Cities Airport. Outside of a couple of minor delays at each departure of less than 15 minutes each, and the need to turn the plan off and back on again at O'Hare, the flights were also trouble free.

The team at Green Family Hyundai in Moline, IL treated me very well. They picked me up at the airport and had Voltron ready to go. The paperwork process was fairly painless and they had me out the door in a very reasonable amount of time.  They have a great facility and are very forward thinking about EVs with a great selection of both new and used cars. Doug the salesman and Tyler the business manager made the whole process run smoothly.


Departure

I was hoping to data log the trip back, but in the morning rush I did not grab my OBDII port tool.  This is not a big deal as the application that I use in Elektra, that I thought would work with Voltron, does not actually support 2023 and beyond vehicles.  Anyway, I was off heading east toward home.  I got on I-80 East at exit 9 and proceeded to head directly west.  When I left the dealership the GOM showed an overly optimistic range of 340 miles.  My first stop was 150 miles away in Orland Park, IL.  Compared to the cold and wind and unknowns of the first stretch when I brought home Elektra that was a 100 mile stretch, this first leg had no concerns.  I followed I-80 East to exit 145 and headed north on US-45 for 5 miles to the mall parking lot for my first charging session.  I was a little nervous heading to the site as all the live data I was seeing was showing 3 of 4 units in use.  All it would take is one more car to show up and charge, and then I would be waiting or looking for other options.  However, when I arrived only 2 of the 4 units were in use.  There was a F150 Lightining and a MB EQE SUV charging, or idling with no drivers in site.  Knowing this was going to be a quick stop, I plugged into the CCS/ChaDemo unit at the end.  Since I had set the car to precondition the battery for the stop, the car almost immediately went to 170kW charging speed.  The advantage of the 800V architecture in the eGMP cars, is that they often pull the maximum power from stations.


Leaving this site, I was trying to be smart and avoid the tolls where I-80 and I-94 meet.  I opted to follow US-6 East towards I-57 and then head south to I-94 avoiding the tolls.  This was going well, if a little slow, until there was a train stopped on a crossing.  A long detour, and sitting in traffic later and I was back on the highway.
 

I planned 2 charging stops, one on the south side of Chicago and then another in the Kalamazoo area in Michigan.  With a rated range of 300 miles, I could have done the trip in one stop, but 2 stops breaks the trip up into somewhat equal 2+ hour legs of driving. For the second stop of the trip home, I was looking for a stop in the Kalamazoo area. Now, I have already been to the Electrify America location here multiple times and know that it is not a good road trip stop, due to it being far from the highway on a very busy road. I was looking for something that could potentially provide peak charging speeds. I found that the West Michigan International heavy duty truck facility was showing as having two 350kW units available. This stop provided an easier on/off highway experience and was cheaper than the Electrify America location. This stop on the west side of Kalamazoo is 130 miles from home, leaving me a quick final 2-hour leg of driving.

One of the two dispensers was clearly marked as out of order, and it seems like the associated power module was also not working. According to the technical data sheet for these ABB Terra HP chargers a single unit can do 175kW max and 375A max. They can be paired to provide up to 350kW and 500A maximum output. Since, I never saw more than 175kW power output, I am assuming that only one of the 2 power cabinets was working during my visit. I did note that the cables were properly rated and cooled, so 400V cars can pull the 375-500A listed and not be cable limited. Even with the limited power, after plugging in at 25%, I was ready to leave the station just 18 minutes later with an 80% charge. Doing the math the car averaged 165kW which is a really good speed to go from 25% to 80%.


The rest of the drive went without issue and I arrived home with about 30%. With the heavy cross winds and colder temperatures, I only averaged 3.2 miles per kWh on the drive home. Definitely would need to get better efficiency than that to achieve the 305 mile rated range of the car, but I am quickly learning this car is not the winter range winner. Hopefully with warmer weather the numbers will improve on highway driving. I look forward to updating some site reviews and planning all new trips, which will go faster with a car that is more efficient and faster charging.


Monday, April 8, 2024

Service Plaza - Tiffin River

 Introduction

Site review from my trip reviewing all of the Electrify America locations in Ohio.


Business/Location Name

Tiffin River Service Plaza

Address

Ohio Turnpike Eastbound – Mile marker 21

Network

Electrify America 

Station Details

4 Stations (2 x 350kW/ 2 x 150kW)

Cost

$0.48 per kWh ($0.36 member price)


The Tiffin River Service Plaza Electrify America station was the 14th and final stop on my trip exploring charging sites across Ohio.  (This station opened in June 2019).  



A car at a gas station

Description automatically generated


Accessibility

The Tiffin River Service Plaza site is located on the I-80/90 Ohio Turnpike.  This service plaza is at mile marker 21.  The units themselves are placed in the main parking lot on the far corner from the facilities.  The 4 units are placed in a side-by-side layout in a 2 by 1 by 1 arrangement.  The EVSE placement does not allow for pull-through parking.


Amenities

Dining options include: Burger King, Sbarro, Starbucks

Shopping options include: 7-Eleven Convenience Store

Car-related services (windshield cleaning, air):  Sunoco gas station at this location.


Concentration

This is a baseline 4 charger site for Electrify America.  This station is park beside/next to configuration.  I didn’t have an issue connecting the Polestar 2 with the driver side port.  With 3 units near the sidewalk, it may cause issues for more vehicles than the standard layout.  This layout is good for side or fender port locations but are more challenging for front port charging vehicles.


Location

This site is on the eastbound side of the turnpike, to the west of Toledo.  Positioned well to support traffic headed from west to east, with the next site to the east further along the turnpike just east of Toledo.  Toledo and Detroit would be major cities easily served by this location.


50 Mile Loop:


150 to 200 Mile Range Estimate:

A map of a city

Description automatically generated


Speed

Electrify America has chargers that support the fastest speeds available today.  The sites support both 350kW and 150kW stations and are well equipped to handle the charging needs of current electric cars and those to come.  The made in September of 2018 Signet charging units have been supporting most Ohio locations for 4 years already.



Close-up of a charging station label

Description automatically generated


Getting the maximum speed the Polestar 2 can charge at:

A screen shot of a car

Description automatically generated


Summary

Nearing the end of my second full day of driving and site reviews, I was still seeing maximum speeds.  The 24 minute stop here gave me a chance to grab some lunch and stretch my legs before I drove home.  This site was okay for a turnpike stop with all the minimally needed features.  The number of Tesla chargers here easily dwarfs the existing infrastructure, hopefully these will open soon to vehicles that support the adapter and network access.  The cost at this site has gone up significantly since my visit and is now $0.64 per kWh.  I assume this is mostly due to demand charges from the local utility provider, as there is not a lot of infrastructure in the area to support this kind of sudden power draw.


A gas station with cars parked in the parking lot

Description automatically generated


What I paid for this stop:

Total Cost: $12.60

Total kWh: 35.292 kWh

Time: 23.5 minutes

Average Charge Speed: 90 kW

Cost per kWh: $0.36




A screenshot of a phone

Description automatically generated



Total Score (Max 44)

Score

Accessibility

Amenities

Usability

31

B

5

5

21


Questions/Comments:
DanTheEVMan@gmail.com

Saturday, April 6, 2024

Service Plaza - Indian Meadows

 Introduction

Site review from my trip reviewing all of the Electrify America locations in Ohio.


Business/Location Name

Indian Meadows Service Plaza

Address

Ohio Turnpike Westbound – Mile marker 21

Network

Electrify America 

Station Details

4 Stations (2 x 350kW/ 2 x 150kW)

Cost

$0.48 per kWh ($0.36 member price)


The Indian Meadows Service Plaza Electrify America station was the 13th stop on my trip  exploring charging sites across Ohio.  (This station opened in June 2019).  



A white gas station with cars in the background

Description automatically generated


Accessibility

The Indian Meadows Service Plaza site is located on the I-80/90 Ohio Turnpike.  This service plaza is at mile marker 21.  The units themselves are placed in the main parking lot on the far corner from the facilities,in a side-by-side layout with 4 available parking spots.  The EVSE placement does not allow for pull-through parking.


Amenities

Dining options include: Burger King, Sbarro, Starbucks

Shopping options include: 7-Eleven Convenience Store

Car-related services (windshield cleaning, air):  Sunoco gas station at this location.


Concentration

This is a baseline 4 charger site for Electrify America.  This station is a park alongside configuration.  I didn’t have an issue connecting the Polestar 2 with the driver side port, but on this trip, I did see a Kia EV6 driver struggle to connect with the passenger rear port location.  These layouts are good for side or fender port locations but are more challenging for front port charging vehicles.


A car charging station with cars parked in the back

Description automatically generated with medium confidence


Location

This site is on the westbound side of the turnpike, to the west of Toledo.  It’s positioned well to support traffic headed from east to west, with the next site to the west further along the turnpike in Indiana near South Bend.  Fort Wayne to the southwest is another large city supported as a destination from this site.


50 Mile Loop:

A map with a green circle

Description automatically generated


150 to 200 Mile Range Estimate:

A map of a city

Description automatically generated


Speed

Electrify America has chargers that support the fastest speeds available today.  The sites support both 350kW and 150kW stations and are well equipped to handle the current amount of electric cars and those yet to come.  The made in August of 2018 Signet charging units have been supporting most Ohio locations for 4 years already.


A close-up of a charging station

Description automatically generated


Summary

This was my next-to-last stop.  I stopped only for the quick charge test as the next stop would be my last,longer stop before driving home.  The site is laid out the same as all the other service plaza stops.  I was able to hit peak charge rates and add 15% into the battery in the 6.5-minute stop.  I wasn’t sure why this and some other sites ended up charging me less than the advertised $0.36 per kWh, but I am not going to complain about cheaper electricity. 


A white car parked in a parking lot

Description automatically generated


What I paid for this stop:

Total Cost: $4.68

Total kWh: 13.882 kWh

Time: 6.5 minutes

Average Charge Speed:  128 kW

Cost per kWh: $0.34


A screenshot of a phone

Description automatically generated


A screenshot of a phone

Description automatically generated



Total Score (Max 44)

Score

Accessibility

Amenities

Usability

31

B

5

5

21


Questions/Comments:
DanTheEVMan@gmail.com

Saturday, March 23, 2024

Service Plaza - Blue Heron

 Introduction

Site review from my trip to review all the Electrify America locations in Ohio.


Business/Location Name

Blue Heron Service Plaza

Address

Ohio Turnpike Westbound – Mile marker 77

Network

Electrify America 

Station Details

4 Stations (2 x 350kW/ 2 x 150kW)

Cost

$0.48 per kWh ($0.36 member price)


The Blue Heron Service Plaza Electrify America station was the 12th stop on my trip exploring the charging sites across Ohio.  (This station opened in May 2019).  



Accessibility

This Blue Heron Service Plaza site is located on the I-80/90 Ohio Turnpike.  This service plaza is at about mile marker 77 on the westbound side of the highway.  The units themselves are placed in the main parking lot on the far corner from the facilities, in a side-by-side layout with 4 available parking spots.  The EVSE placement does not allow for pull-through parking.  (This site is opposite side of the turnpike from my first stop of this trip)


Amenities

Dining options include: Hardee’s, Marco’s Pizza

Shopping options include: Pike Plaza Shop

Car-related services (windshield cleaning, air):  Sunoco gas station at this location.


Concentration

This is a baseline 4 charger site for Electrify America.  This station is park beside/next to configuration.  I didn’t have an issue connecting the Polestar 2 with the driver side port, but on this trip, I did see a Kia EV6 struggle to connect with the passenger rear port location.  These layouts are good for side or fender port locations but are more challenging for front port charging vehicles.


Location

This site is on the westbound side of the turnpike, on the east side of Toledo and is positioned well to support traffic headed from east to west, with the next site to the west further along the turnpike towards Indiana and the Chicago area.


50 Mile Loop:


150 to 200 Mile Range Estimate:

A map of a city

Description automatically generated



Speed

Electrify America has chargers that support the fastest speeds available today.  The sites support both 350kW and 150kW stations and are well equipped to handle the current amount of electric cars and those yet to come.  The made in March of 2018 Signet charging units have been supporting most Ohio locations for 4 years already


A close-up of a charging station

Description automatically generated



Summary

Based on my preliminary research, I knew that only 2 of the 4 units at this stop were working, same as the last stop.  As I got on the turnpike, I noticed that an Ioniq 5 entered behind me.  I was worried that we were both planning to stop at the service plaza stop and if someone was already there, it would be a wait.  As we approached the service plaza, there was a EV6 that seemed to be drafting a semi-truck.  The Ioniq 5 didn’t stop, and I chose to leave the 350kW unit for the EV6 and took the 150kW unit to charge.  Unfortunately, due to where I parked the driver of the EV6 had a hard time parking to plug in.  Fortunately, the EV6 was headed back to MI and was just doing a quick top up to make it home.  Unfortunately, the 150kW only gave me 41kW.  This site scores a B, about what you can expect from a service plaza stop with limited amenities.



A group of cars parked in a parking lot

Description automatically generated



What I paid for this stop:

Total Cost: $2.52

Total kWh: 7.299

Time: 11 minutes

Average Charge Speed: 39.8 kW

Cost per kWh: $0.35


A screenshot of a phone

Description automatically generated




Total Score (Max 44)

Score

Accessibility

Amenities

Usability

31

B

5

5

21


Questions/Comments:
DanTheEVMan@gmail.com

Introduction

Introduction Who am I? I’m an Electric Vehicle (EV) enthusiast from the metro Detroit area and the new owner of possibly the only Kia Niro E...